Enjoy reading these - tks for posting here. You are, as you warn, harsh, which is good. But all seem quite fair grades. Was thinking B+ for Shibuno is a bit lenient - but I guess her season has been deceptively good (and perhaps I had too high expectations). Can't argue with #30 on Race to CME (current standings, but will drop a bit after Evian performance - or lack thereof, haha) - but she should be contending more.
Na Rin's B might be a bit inflated - but again maybe I'm clouded by expectations. From her IG posts from a while ago, I don't think she's been completely healthy lately, which would account for her recent bad play.
Like So Yeon Ryu I saw Maddie Szeryk win the first Tournament she played as a Pro on the Cactus Tour. She was also a great golfer at Texas A&M. The only thing that I figured would hold her back is her distance off the tee. Still her game was solid and I thought she would be farther along on the Tour by now.